I am not sure where to begin. I recently read a novel by a respected author who pens fiction and non with equal finesse and who always leaves me questioning, thinking, wanting to know more about the subject matter, the main character, something mentioned on page 243 . . .
I’ll begin at the beginning. Dellarobia Turnbow is trekking up the mountainside wearing secondhand boots bought for their color. It is one of the few things she has that is just hers. She is trudging along in the mud, for the area has been experiencing rain of Biblical proportions, without her eye glasses, in search of an affair with a telephone man, when she discovers the Turnbow forest aflame. Like Moses at the burning bush, Dellarobia is transfixed and her life is forever changed, in ways she could not have imagined when she began her defiant walk.
So begins Barbara Kingsolver’s “Flight Behavior”.
What Dellarobia saw with her myopic vision was not a forest in flames. What she saw were monarchs, off course. As off course as Dellarobia and all those around her will be as the news media, the internet, protesters and entomologists descend on her Appalachian town in a “what if” sort of story that touches upon issues of climate change, disparity in education, poverty, science, religion, despair and hope.
When Della’s husband, Cub, makes an announcement in church that his family, encouraged by his wife’s vision, came upon millions of “king billies” on their forested mountain, all havoc breaks lose. The forest is scheduled to be clear cut for money to pay back a “balloon” loan payment, among other things. Entomologist, Dr. Ovid Byron, sets up camp in a trailer on Cub and Dellarobia’s property, and, later a lab in the sheep barn. Both bring some excitement, rent money, and even a job for Dellarobia. It also brings the outside world to their home, a house built on the Turnbow property by Cub’s parents when Della was 17, pregnant, and suddenly married.
The Turnbow’s live on the edge of poverty, barely eking out enough money to get by. Dellarobia is a young woman with two children and unfulfilled dreams of going to college and living a better life. Cub is a good man who is uninspired and brow-beaten by his father, Bear, and his mother, Hester, who has some secrets of her own. Together, they raise sheep, do odd jobs, and hang on to life as best they can.
There is so much I can say about this book. How I came to like, even love, the characters, especially Dellarobia. How kind Dr. Byron is; how attentive to Della’s young son, encouraging his questions and interest in science. How I laughed out loud at Della’s wit and perspectives, How I wanted to throttle Bear and how I came to understand Hester.
There are so many issues raised in “Flight Behavior”; climate change, responsibility for actions, care of the environment, distrust of scientists, the influence of the news media, how those most directly impacted by environmental and other issues are the ones most often forgotten. Stereotypes and prejudices, stubbornness and impulsiveness.
There is a moment where an activist implores Dellarobia to sign an environmental pledge, as she sits on a folding chair, in the rain, on the mountain, counting monarchs for Dr. Byron. Della, whose carbon footprint is miniscule, shops with food stamps and conserves on heat because they can’t afford to pay their bills, is chided to eat local and more fruits and vegetables while she is trying the best she can to stop the logging proposal, which will likely cause mudslides and the demise of life as she and her family know it, replies
“Are you crazy? I’m trying to increase our intake of red meat.”
“Why is that?”
“Because mac and cheese only gets you so far, is why. We have lamb, we produce that on our farm. But I don’t have a freezer. I have to get it from my in-laws.”
This isn’t about becoming a vegetarian, putting on more blankets, or not using paper plates. It is more, to me, about how we approach concerns, how sometimes activism loses people to their cause because of insensitivity or ignorance. So much of what happens in our lives is interpreted from our own personal perspectives, isn’t it? I read “Flight Behavior” as I pondered the one monarch seen thus far this summer her on the Cutoff, and four or five bumble bees spotted. I read it on an unseasonably cool Fourth of July while firestorms ravaged the southwest and rains fell on the British Isles. I wondered, as I read, and I laughed, grew angry, forgiving – then, as the book ended, I shed some tears of “what if?”
Have you read Barbara Kingsolver’s “Flight Behavior” or any of her other books?
Ok, you’ve hooked me. This is going to the top of my TBR list. That is, after I read every thing about Anne and my other friends on PEI. That won’t take long, however. I’m partly through already.
LikeLike
You’re fast. I barely got this posted, and here you are! I do hope you will read it, Janet. Save it from when you come home from your “visit with Anne”.
LikeLike
No, Penny, I haven’t; but now I want to! You do great justice to every book review you write!
LikeLike
Thank you, Karen. That is so kind of you to say. I hope you will find the book – and find it a good read.
LikeLike
Penny, I hope I can persuade you to review a book of mine someday. I cannot stand Barbara Kingsolver’s writing. Can’t stand it. And you still made me want to check out this book. Well done.
LikeLike
I will be honored to review any book of yours, Andra, no persuasion necessary – and I won’t hold your opinion of Barbara Kingsolver against you, either. Thank you.
LikeLike
A really stirring review. This sounds like a must-read, Penny, a book which changes how we percieve things.
LikeLike
Thank you, Kate. It certainly made me re-think the ways we approach such issues, Kate, especially on issues that we are all facing these days. You might enjoy her.
LikeLike
I haven’t read it yet but have it on the list of books I want to read for my southern literature challenge. I’m so pleased you loved it… what a super review!
LikeLike
Thank you, Cath. I did enjoy it and I’ll be interested in your thoughts on “Flight Behavior” – and your other southern literature reads.
LikeLike
I have this on order from the library, along with about 100 others. So it will be a wait, but I know from your post that it will be well worth waiting for. Thank you Penny.
LikeLike
You are welcome Juliet. I had to renew this two times from the library before I could find time to sit down for a good read. It was worth it. This book moved me and made me think of things a little differently. I hope you enjoy it as well.
LikeLike
I do have this book, Penny, but I haven’t read it! You’ve given me just enough taste for me to prioritize. We are leaving for the beach in just under two weeks, and I’ll take this as one to devour. I do like Kingsolver. I read Poisonwood Bible so long ago I don’t remember the details! I loved Prodigal Summer, and Animal, Vegetable, Miracle actually became a catalyst to a great deal of change in my diet and my relationship with food. I think I could say that Barbara Kingsolver was responsible for alerting me to the importance of eating local. I think she’s a fantastic author. So Flight Behavior is next. Thank you, Penny. I am still thinking about our concerns for Monarchs. I’ll finish this book and maybe we can continue that conversation!
LikeLike
I’d love to hear your reaction to “Flight Behavior”, Debra, and look forward to it. This is fiction, of course, but, it raises a great many questions, not only about monarchs, but, other issues as well. We read “Poisonwood Bible” for our book group and had a lively discussion. Actually, we’ve read quite a few Kingsolver books over they years. I think the first one was “Pigs in Heaven”, which I loved. I haven’t read “Animal, Vegetable, Miracle” as yet. Need to do that. Summer is so good for eating local in these parts, as farmers haul in their crops for local markets. I love that – and hope to soon be harvesting a few vegetables from our own little plot of land.
LikeLike
I have a friend who keeps trying to persuade me to try Barbara Kingsolver, Penny, but so far I haven’t succumbed. This intriguing review may just have done the trick. 🙂 When I get back to the UK I must check our library catalogue for her works.
LikeLike
I wonder if your friend has recommended a particular book, Perpetua. Just curious. Barbara Kingsolver has a pretty substantial body of work. I hope whatever you find is enjoyable for you. I also hope the weather has been cooperating. (Flight Behavior is set in a period of time with unusual rainfalls.)
LikeLike
I am so pleased you enjoyed this Penny. I knew you would ! I was overcome by it. The family dynamics, the development of Dellarobia’s self awareness, her beautiful understanding of her own situation, and what might have been, or what could be, and of course the overwhelming environmental issues raised so sensitively…recognising other’s views, based on ignorance, lack of understanding, political otherness, and very often, financial necessity.
I too love the bit where the environmental footprint is discussed….the idea that Della should take less flights ! One of my favourite bits is when she describes the extent of her science education…..or when Byron foolishly assumes that local high school kids would relish the idea of helping with the project, having no understanding that the kids would do nothing outside school that didn’t earn them money.
I cried several times in the book….over the big issues, wanting the monarchs to survive the freeze, wanting them to fly off where they should be, and over Dellarobia’s situation…her bittersweet relationship with her husband and her son, and her mother in law….actually I wanted another book, about the mother in law. Yes, yes, yes…..a powerful, beautifully written and important book. I loved it. Jx
LikeLike
I am so glad you mentioned the book, Janice, and then, as if providence stepped in, it popped up in front of me at the library. (Don’t tell anyone, but, I was so busy this summer that I had to renew it two times before I had I chance to dig into it. Ha!) Once I had time, I couldn’t put it down. You say it all perfectly in your comment here. There is so much to digest; so many issues. Dellarobia’s character developed well, for me, as did Hester. All the assumptions people have of each other; Byron has as many about Dellarobia and her circumstances as she does about him, for instance. I didn’t see the revelation about the preacher, Bobby, coming. Aha! and I admired the way the scientists worked with Della, and with her son. I shed a tear over the watch for Christmas.
The ended left me wanting more as well. I would not be surprised if there is another book, much like Pigs in Heaven and then, was it High Tide in Tuscon. I still remember the little girl. Turtle. Funny how a character can stay with you.
Janice, I’m sorry it took me so long to reply. Somehow, your comment was hiding in the spam, then, I couldn’t get it out! Finally did, and now thank you for the recommendation and for taking the time to comment. Wish we could sit down over a cup of something and chat in person.
LikeLike
I’ve read all her other books, except the one about going local foods for a year (it’s on my list, but just keeps getting pushed down),,, somehow I missed knowing about this one (we don’t have a good newspaper in Florida and I miss reviews sometimes). So now I will add this one. Every book of hers I’ve read has left me in the same state as you describe after reading this one.
LikeLike
Barbara Kingsolver’s writing has that effect, doesn’t it, Sallie? Flight Behavior might have passed me by if Janice in Caunes had not mentioned it, reminding me I wanted to read it. I am so glad I did. I haven’t read Animal, Vegetable, Miracle (I think that’ the title), either, but we probably both understand the need to eat local. I hope you have a chance to read Flight Behavior.
LikeLike